The 1992 baseball team
As the Texas Intercollegiate Athletic Association (TIAA) champion, the team went 39-23 overall, and 2-2 at the NAIA District 8 Tournament hosted by Dallas Baptist University.
Howard Payne was the #4 seed, defeating (#5 seed) College of the Southwest 6-3 and (#1 seed) Lubbock Christian 7-6. HPU would fall to (#2 seed) Dallas Baptist 3-13 and (#3 seed) Tarleton State 7-14.
Post-season awards included 1992 All-District 8 Baseball Team members David White – OF – Sr., Beck Wells – C – Jr.
1992 District 8 All-Tournament Team members Beck Wells – C, Andy Johnson – OF, Travis Paige – P, and TIAA Coach of the Year, Todd Howey.

The 1993 baseball team
Gaining the 1993 TIAA Championship, the Yellow Jackets finished the 1993 season at 37-20 overall, and appeared for the second straight year at the NAIA District 8 Tournament hosted by Tarleton State University.
Post-season awards included 1993 All-District 8 Baseball Team members Damon Treadway – UTL, and Beck Wells – C. Wells would also be named an All-American.
All-TIAA members were, Rudy Ramos -P, Damon Treadway – P, Beck Wells – C, Pepper Wells – 3B, James Bybee – OF, Greg Burnet – UTL, Todd Bentley – P, Jeff Turner – OF, Michael Ornelaz – UTL., and TIAA Coach of the Year, Todd Howey

The 1994 baseball team
Finishing with the program's third consecutive TIAA Championship, HPU posted a 22-26 overall record, and the team went 1-2 at the NAIA District 8 Tournament hosted by Hardin-Simmons. The Yellow Jackets defeated host HSU in the first round 7-2.
Post-season awards included 1994 All-District 8 Baseball Team members Shawn Hughes, and Greg Burnet. All-TIAA members Rudy Ramos – P, Todd Brantley – P, Travis McMain – P, Pepper Wells – UTL, James Bybee – OF, Jeff Turner – OF, Michael Ornelaz – SS, Shawn Hughes – C, and TIAA MVP Greg Burnet. Todd Howey would be named the TIAA Coach of the Year for the third consecutive season.
The team set a school record for playing in 40 consecutive games without being shut out.